By Tiffany Stanley, Particular To The Washington Publish
At first, it appeared just like the abdomen flu. Weeks earlier than his 24th birthday in Might 2015, Alec Raeshawn Smith was overcome by troubling signs. His physique ached, his abdomen harm and he wasn’t sleeping nicely. Laine Lu, a co-worker at his restaurant job, urged him to see a physician. “This is not normal,” she recollects telling him. “Go get checked out.”
His mom, Nicole Smith-Holt, frightened too. He referred to as her when he determined to go to a well being clinic close to Minneapolis. He stated, “Seriously, Mom, I think something is really wrong with me.”
The analysis was shocking: Sort 1 diabetes. Alec’s blood sugar ranges have been almost twice the wholesome restrict. His household didn’t have a historical past of diabetes, and lanky, 6-foot-Three Alec appeared like the image of well being. At 23, he appeared too previous for Sort 1 diabetes, as soon as generally known as juvenile diabetes as a result of it typically strikes youngsters. However as Alec found, Sort 1 diabetes is an autoimmune response that may seem at any age. It isn’t preventable, and there’s no recognized remedy.
On the clinic, a nurse practitioner mentioned the potential problems of the continual illness, together with blindness, nerve injury, and kidney and coronary heart issues, in accordance to medical data. Alec got here house with prescriptions for 2 sorts of insulin: One was long-acting; the opposite gave him brief bursts earlier than meals. He wrote on Fb: “Today a lot has changed. . . . I would never wish this upon anybody. So whoever reads this take care of yourself.”
Even for his older sister, Brittany Smith, who’s a nurse, the training curve about Sort 1 diabetes was steep. “I didn’t really have a handle on it,” she says. Most of her diabetic sufferers had the much more widespread Sort 2. Each varieties contain an imbalance of insulin, a hormone that helps regulate blood glucose ranges. For Sort 1 diabetics, the physique produces little to no insulin. In Sort 2, usually, the physique has turn out to be resistant to insulin’s results. Not all Sort 2 diabetics take insulin, however all Sort 1 diabetics do. Alec would wish a gentle provide for the remaining of his life.
What had been a carefree 20-something existence was now dominated by insulin injections, timing of doses and taking a blood pattern 4 occasions a day to measure glucose ranges. “I know he’d get frustrated,” Nicole says. Inside three months, although, Alec had gotten his blood sugar beneath management. He maintained wholesome ranges as that first yr wore on. He started courting Laine and labored as a supervisor on the restaurant the place they’d met. Ultimately, he moved out of his mother and father’ house and into his personal condo on a tree-lined road close to downtown Minneapolis.
In 2017, as his 26th birthday neared, his mom had a brand new fear: He would not be coated by her medical insurance by means of her job within the monetary assist division of a group school. Nicole paid about $100 per biweekly paycheck for a household plan, and it had not cost additional to embrace Alec. With it, she says, he initially had been paying about $200 to $300 a month out-of-pocket for his diabetic provides and prescriptions, an quantity he might simply afford. The restaurant didn’t supply insurance coverage, and his $35,000 wage put him above the revenue restrict for Medicaid in Minnesota.
His mom helped him search for a well being plan on the marketplace arrange by the Reasonably priced Care Act, however his choices have been costly. To maintain going to the identical docs, she says, he was taking a look at paying about $450 month-to-month, as well as to a excessive deductible of greater than $7,000, which might imply months of paying out-of-pocket for many of his medical care. He opted to go with out insurance coverage, forgoing that expense to give attention to paying for his insulin and provides till he might discover a higher choice.
What Alec quickly discovered was simply how a lot his insulin would find yourself costing: greater than $1,000 a month. The worth of insulin – as soon as modest – has skyrocketed in recent times, making the lifesaving medicine a big, even burdensome, expense, particularly for the uninsured and underinsured. The prices are so heavy that they’ve pushed some sufferers to ration their provides of the drug in a harmful gamble with life-threatening penalties.
On the time Alec mentioned skipping insurance coverage protection, he informed his mom, “It can’t be that bad.” Inside a month of going off her coverage, he can be lifeless.
Insulin, in its numerous manufactured varieties, has been used to deal with diabetes for nearly a century, since Canadian researchers remoted the hormone in a lab in 1921. Earlier than their discovery, what we now know as Sort 1 diabetes was deadly. Even after being placed on hunger diets, sufferers typically lived no various years. The researchers who reworked diabetes remedy gained the Nobel Prize, they usually bought their patent to the College of Toronto for a complete of $Three. “Above all, these were discoverers who were trying to do a great humanitarian thing, and they hoped their discovery was a kind of gift to humanity,” historian Michael Bliss informed The Washington Publish in 2016.
Quickly, although, insulin turned a business enterprise. By 1923, the American pharmaceutical firm Eli Lilly was manufacturing sufficient insulin for diabetics throughout North America. For many years, producers improved formulation, first utilizing animal elements, then producing human insulin utilizing micro organism and recombinant DNA. The 1990s noticed the arrival of insulin analogs, artificial medicine made to higher mimic the physique’s personal insulin manufacturing.
At the moment, critics argue that the worth of insulin has far outpaced any improvements. Prior to now decade alone, U.S. insulin record costs have tripled, in accordance to an evaluation of knowledge from IBM Watson Well being. In 1996, when Eli Lilly debuted its Humalog model of insulin, the record worth of a 10-milliliter vial was $21. The worth of the identical vial is now $275. These prices might be compounded by the a number of vials that diabetics might require to survive every month. “It’s a very big problem,” says Robert Gabbay, chief medical officer on the Joslin Diabetes Middle in Boston. “It’s a tragic barrier to care.”
The worldwide insulin market is dominated by three corporations: Eli Lilly, the French firm Sanofi and the Danish agency Novo Nordisk. All three have raised listing costs to comparable ranges. In accordance to IBM Watson Well being knowledge, Sanofi’s well-liked insulin model Lantus was $35 a vial when it was launched in 2001; it’s now $270. Novo Nordisk’s Novolog was priced at $40 in 2001, and as of July 2018, it’s $289.
In Washington, the hovering worth of insulin has provoked bipartisan concern. Members of Congress try to parse the elements which have brought about the spike. In November, a congressional caucus launched a report on insulin, urging laws aimed toward decreasing costs by means of elevated competitors and pricing transparency, amongst different suggestions. In June, the American Medical Affiliation referred to as on the federal government “to monitor insulin pricing and market competition and take enforcement actions as appropriate.” Insulin, in some methods, serves as a proxy for the rising costs throughout the U.S. prescription drug market. On the marketing campaign path in 2016, Donald Trump railed towards excessive drug costs, and his administration has vowed to decrease them, releasing a flurry of proposals up to now yr.
Within the meantime, a portion of the greater than 7 million diabetic People who take insulin are caught with debilitating prices. Although most don’t pay the complete record worth for insulin as a result of of insurance coverage protection and different rebates, some do, particularly those that are uninsured, underinsured or dealing with a protection hole by way of Medicare. “The most vulnerable patients are subsidizing the system,” William Cefalu, the chief scientific, medical and mission officer of the American Diabetes Affiliation, advised a Senate committee in Might.
On the similar listening to, a father from Maine advised senators that a 90-day prescription for only one of his son’s insulins would cost him $1,489.46. That’s together with his high-deductible insurance coverage. He testified that he has taken to shopping for the identical three-month provide from a Canadian pharmacy for about $300 plus $50 in delivery. (It’s technically unlawful to import medicine from different nations, however the Meals and Drug Administration usually doesn’t prosecute people if it’s a short-term provide for private use.) He isn’t alone in his dilemma: The web site GoFundMe has hundreds of posts with individuals pleading for assist to pay for insulin.
Sufferers who wrestle to afford insulin typically ration their provide to make it last more – a harmful follow that may create disabling or lethal problems. “It’s very shortsighted to skimp on insulin,” says Kasia Lipska, an endocrinologist and diabetes researcher at Yale Faculty of Drugs. “In the long term, it’s going to cost us much more.” Poor glycemic management can lead to blindness, kidney failure, amputation, coronary heart illness and stroke. Within the brief time period, sufferers who cease taking sufficient insulin can lapse into diabetic ketoacidosis, a situation the place blood sugars get too excessive and the physique’s blood turns into acidic. It might develop into deadly in simply hours or a number of days.
On the Yale Diabetes Middle, Lipska and her colleagues just lately discovered that one in 4 diabetic sufferers reported rationing insulin as a result of of the cost. Only a few of these sufferers have been uninsured, however their out-of-pocket bills nonetheless created a monetary burden. These sufferers have been additionally, not surprisingly, virtually 3 times as doubtless to have poor blood sugar management as sufferers who didn’t underuse insulin.
Did Alec die as a result of he was rationing? The reply might by no means be completely clear, however his household is satisfied that he was skimping on his doses. He by no means advised his family members that he was rationing as a result of of the expense, however they knew that the illness and its cost wore on him. He had talked to his mother and father about looking for jobs that provided medical insurance. Laine had scouted the Web for prescription reductions. Alec vented to his greatest pal, Erick Borrome, whose spouse, Arizbeth, provided to get him low cost insulin from a pharmacy in Mexico, the place she had household and a vial cost roughly $50. She says: “We had many conversations about the insulin and the cost. He was pretty worried about it.” However, she provides, “he was too shy to accept help.” He by no means took her up on the supply.
Nicole received the decision that Alec had died on a Tuesday. It was Laine who discovered him. She hadn’t heard from him since Sunday night time, so she went to his condo to verify on him. He was on the ground beside his mattress. “I grabbed his shoulder, and it was ice cold,” Laine says. “I just knew he was gone.”
Alec’s funeral was held the day after the Fourth of July, his favourite vacation. Household and pals gathered at his mother and father’ home in Richfield, a Minneapolis suburb, to shoot off fireworks in his reminiscence. These first few weeks have been a blur, as Nicole tried in her grief to piece collectively the final days of Alec’s life. The medical expert had listed diabetic ketoacidosis (DKA) because the trigger of demise. By definition, he had died of a scarcity of insulin, however why and the way did that occur?
In talking with Laine, Nicole discovered that Alec had indicated he was operating low on insulin earlier than he died. That Sunday, Laine had advised they go to a meals truck pageant, however she remembered Alec saying, “No, I don’t think I have enough insulin for that.” That night time, he was drained and complaining about stomach pains. Listening to this, Nicole deduced that these signs might have been warning indicators of DKA.
There have been extra clues: There was some wholesome meals in his fridge, however no stockpile of insulin. As Nicole cleaned out his cluttered blue automotive, suffering from previous prescription receipts, she began to cobble collectively simply how a lot his insulin and blood sugar testing provides cost with out insurance coverage or reductions. The entire, by her rely, was almost $1,300 per thirty days. That was roughly the identical quantity that Alec’s native pharmacy tallied for me almost a yr later, utilizing an inventory of his drugs and medical provides. “It’s very expensive to be diabetic without insurance,” the pharmacist stated. That $1,300 was virtually $200 greater than Alec’s biweekly paycheck.
Nicole now believes that Alec was rationing his insulin as a result of of the cost. “Based upon what he had left when he was found, we came to the conclusion that he had not filled his prescription, so he had to have been rationing for a short period of time,” Nicole informed me. “We realized that he had been taking less insulin and less often than he should, trying to make it stretch until he got his next paycheck.” He was discovered lifeless three days earlier than payday.
Nobody can really know what occurred in these ultimate days. Alec might not have realized that his situation was so critical, or maybe he thought he can be effective, simply as he had been when he was recognized. DKA creates confusion because it progresses, and it may progress shortly, shutting down very important organs.
“If I could go back in time,” Nicole says, “I would have found a way for him to not move out . . . so I could monitor this or see that he was struggling in some kind of way, and force him to take our help.” One afternoon, sitting at their eating room desk, her husband, James Holt, recalled encouraging Alec to get his personal place. “I think back and regret that,” he stated, wiping away tears.
Of their seek for solutions,there was sufficient blame to go round. His household blamed the damaged health-care system. They blamed unaffordable insurance coverage and excessive out-of-pocket prices. They blamed rather a lot of issues, together with, in darker moments, themselves. However they stored coming again to the worth of insulin. Why was a remedy that had been round for almost 100 years so costly? And what could possibly be carried out about it?
Nicole hadn’t recognized a lot concerning the world of diabetes advocacy earlier than Alec died. However now she felt a budding activism as she encountered a flood of info and tales like her personal on-line.
Advocates have been rallying across the hashtag #insulin4all, which the nonprofit group T1International helped create in 2014 to increase consciousness concerning the inaccessibility of insulin, notably in creating nations. T1International’s founder, Elizabeth Pfiester, an American Sort 1 diabetic who now lives in the UK, nonetheless marvels at how far more reasonably priced diabetes care is in her adopted nation. “It’s really a shame that #insulin4all is needed as a rallying cry in the U.S.,” she says.
There are T1International activists like Hattie Saltzman, a university scholar in Missouri who went a yr with out shopping for insulin as a result of she couldn’t afford her month-to-month $550 insulin invoice. Her father shared some of his insulin, and she or he obtained free samples from her physician. At one level, she informed me, “I had rationed insulin so extensively that it expired. I didn’t catch that until I went to the ER because my blood sugars were through the roof.” When the diabetic daughter of household buddies died of cystic fibrosis, the household donated her leftover insulin to Saltzman. That received her by way of the yr till she certified for higher insurance coverage protection.
There are new instances on a regular basis. In July, Lengthy Island resident Doreen Rudolph tweeted about her younger grownup daughter’s wrestle to afford insulin: “I just bought 2 vials of insulin for my daughter cost me $524. With a discount card. All I could buy. I left the pharmacy and sat in my car and cried.” Her message struck a chord: Inside 5 days, her tweet had been appreciated 70,000 occasions, and her $eight,000 GoFundMe marketing campaign was absolutely funded. To purchase insulin, Rudolph advised me, “We’ve taken out loans. We’ve borrowed from retirement. You assume, ‘Where else can I get it?’ “
A pharmacist and a quantity of physicians advised me about older insulins obtainable from Walmart. The sort of insulin first got here out within the 1980s and now prices about $25 per vial. So-called “Walmart insulin” is a controversial answer for Sort 1 diabetics, many of whom consider that older formulation are extra doubtless to lead to dangerously low blood sugar ranges. A number of docs echoed that concern. But it might nonetheless save lives. “It’s very good insulin,” one doctor informed me. One other stated, “It’s obviously better than nothing.” Researchers have discovered that these older insulins work simply as nicely for Sort 2 diabetics as pricier analog insulins, however some analysis exhibits a barely higher consequence for Sort 1 diabetics on newer formulation.
Many diabetics proceed to hunt for coupons and reductions on high-priced insulins. Some docs will give out samples to struggling sufferers. The fixed seek for extra insulin can turn out to be all-consuming. “I think about it when I wake up. I think about it when I go to bed,” says Michelle Fenner, an #insulin4all activist whose diabetic son is 17. She worries about what is going to occur when he’s a younger grownup and on his personal. “There is no way he can pay what I do,” she says.
Eli Lilly, which hasn’t raised its insulin costs since Might 2017, declines to talk about its pricing methods typically. Requested for remark, it provided a press release: “Some people pay too much for insulin at the pharmacy, and there are several reasons – including high deductible insurance plans that require people to pay thousands of dollars in medical bills before coverage is triggered. We’re focused on finding solutions to the problem.”
In August, the corporate began the Lilly Diabetes Answer Middle, a assist line to “assist people who need help paying for their insulin.” Fenner stated a coupon she acquired from the assistance line dropped the month-to-month cost of one of her son’s insulins from $900 to $95. It’s an unimaginable boon, however she already worries how lengthy Eli Lilly will hold the financial savings going. In accordance to the American Diabetes Affiliation, these sorts of measures are only a stopgap: The group’s June 2018 report concluded that company affected person help packages are “not deemed to be a long-term or comprehensive answer to the rising cost of insulin for the vast majority of people with diabetes.” A number of individuals, together with Fenner, described insulin as being like oxygen: Scavenging for it invokes a primal worry, just like the gasp you make simply earlier than you run out of air.
In early Might, 10 months after Alec died, Nicole flew to Indianapolis to attend a shareholder assembly at Eli Lilly headquarters. Her journey had been coordinated partially by T1International. Earlier than the assembly, a small band of activists gathered outdoors. One held a neon-pink poster that learn: “Your insulin is a life saver. Your prices are poison.”
Digital camera crews arrange on a road nook. For greater than half an hour, Nicole answered the identical questions from reporters. Why are you right here? What would you like from Eli Lilly? She informed them she was there for Alec. “I feel like I am leaving a legacy for him,” she stated. “That’s what is really important to me. I don’t want any other person to die the way that he did. If I can prevent it, that’s what I’m here to do.”
Nicole needed pharmaceutical corporations to begin by being extra clear about their costs – to disclose how a lot it prices to manufacture a vial of insulin and what the revenue margin on every vial is. Finally, she needed them to scale back the worth. “They’re going to tell you it’s complicated or they can’t share that information with you,” she stated to a reporter. “It’s not all that complicated. They’re choosing to make it complicated. It’s just plain greed.”
The rising costs from Eli Lilly, Sanofi and Novo Nordisk have raised suspicions. The businesses seem to have elevated them in lockstep over a quantity of years, prompting allegations of worth fixing. All three corporations denied these fees once I contacted them. (In 2010, Mexico fined Eli Lilly and three Mexican corporations for worth collusion on insulin, an allegation Eli Lilly additionally denied.) In america, a federal prosecutor and no less than 5 state attorneys common are presently investigating the businesses’ pricing practices, in accordance to Kaiser Well being Information. In October, Minnesota turned the primary state to sue the businesses over insulin costs. And in January 2017, potential class-action lawsuits alleging worth fixing by the three corporations started making their method by way of the courts on behalf of diabetics. The businesses denied the fits’ allegations.
There’s additionally one other, much less recognized company entity within the combine: pharmacy profit managers (PBMs), which embrace Categorical Scripts, OptumRx and CVS Well being; all at the moment are named in lawsuits on excessive insulin costs, however these corporations additionally deny any wrongdoing. PBMs handle the prescription drug advantages which are half of insurance policy, working with pharmaceutical corporations to negotiate reductions on behalf of insurance coverage suppliers. “Every time a PBM extracts a deeper discount, an insulin manufacturer has the incentive to take a price increase to quote ‘make themselves whole,’ ” says Rena Conti, a well being economist at Boston College. That’s in all probability one purpose why, whilst Eli Lilly’s listing worth for Humalog insulin has elevated by 175 % since 2009, the corporate maintains that its internet worth – the quantity the corporate earns after rebates, reductions and costs – has remained regular.
Each drug corporations and PBMs play a task in escalating drug costs. “It’s almost like Kabuki theater where one guy points to the other guy and says, ‘It’s not me, it’s him,’ ” says Jing Luo, an teacher at Harvard Medical Faculty and a school member at Boston’s Brigham and Ladies’s Hospital who research insulin pricing.
These company entities are highly effective particular pursuits. In 2017, the pharmaceutical and well being product business – which incorporates drug corporations and PBMs – spent almost $280 million on lobbying, the most important spender by far of 20 prime industries, in accordance to the Middle for Responsive Politics. Even some affected person advocacy organizations, just like the American Diabetes Affiliation, obtain tens of millions in funding from pharmaceutical corporations. The business additionally has a revolving door to authorities. Alex Azar, the top of the Division of Well being and Human Providers, was the president of Eli Lilly’s U.S. division till 2017. Underneath his watch, the worth of the corporate’s analog insulin doubled. Now he’s tasked with overseeing the federal government’s plan to decrease those self same costs.
At Eli Lilly, Nicole met with Mike Mason, the vice chairman of U.S. Lilly’s diabetes division. The corporate declined to make Mason obtainable for an interview for this text, however Nicole says he appeared compassionate. She held a photograph of Alec in the course of the assembly and positioned it on the desk in entrance of her whereas she learn a press release. “Profits should never come before the lives of people,” she advised Mason and the opposite representatives within the room, earlier than asking them to keep in mind her household’s grief. She struggled to keep her composure, she informed me later, however when she introduced up “corporate greed” with Mason, she says, “I stopped and looked him dead in the face. He looked away.”
On Might 11, 4 days after Nicole’s journey to Eli Lilly, President Donald Trump and Azar stood within the White Home Rose Backyard to unveil “American Patients First,” the administration’s “blueprint to lower drug prices and reduce out-of-pocket costs.” The president informed the gang, “We will have tougher negotiation, more competition and much lower prices at the pharmacy counter. And it will start to take effect very soon.”
The blueprint consists of greater than 50 proposals. “There is not a single silver bullet that’s going to reduce drug prices across the board,” says Aaron Kesselheim, an affiliate professor and drug-pricing researcher who’s a colleague of Luo’s at Harvard Medical Faculty and Brigham and Ladies’s Hospital. Some of the proposals are nonstarters, he argues, comparable to punishing different nations for the low costs they pay on medicine. (People pay extra for medicine than some other nationality, however the governments of many different developed nations regulate drug costs, which retains them decrease.) “A better solution would be to focus on what makes our pharmaceutical market inefficient,” Kesselheim says. “Focusing on this concept of foreign freeloading is, I think, a political distraction.”
For Conti, the Boston College economist, the administration’s blueprint doesn’t go far sufficient in addressing insurers. To ensure that “real people pay lower prices” on the pharmacy, the very first thing she would do is remove insurance policy that permit giant out-of-pocket prices for prescribed drugs – together with the type of high-deductible plan that Alec opted not to take. “It’s insurance principles 101,” Conti says. “People should not have to pay significant high prices for accessing a treatment that keeps them well.”
The blueprint general is simply that: a beginning framework. One promising concept requires elevated pricing transparency, a well-liked concept amongst insulin-access activists that has additionally been gaining floor in state legislatures. The blueprint additionally recommends bringing extra generic medicine onto the market. Proper now, the USA has two comparatively new “follow-on” insulins, that are comparable to generics, however they’re solely marginally cheaper. Some specialists say extra competitors is required to decrease costs. In December, FDA Commissioner Scott Gottlieb issued a press release on insurance policies that may put extra generics on the U.S. market, together with for insulin beginning in 2020, as half of a transition that was written into the Reasonably priced Care Act. “We’ve heard frequent reports of patients rationing insulin, and in some cases dying because they can’t afford the injections they need to survive,” the assertion learn. “These tragic stories aren’t isolated occurrences. And they’re not acceptable for a drug that’s nearly a century old.”
Trump has stated that drug corporations are “getting away with murder,” and he has singled them out on Twitter, however some specialists say his administration’s blueprint takes a more durable line on PBMs than it does on pharmaceutical corporations. And although Trump pledged in late Might that drug producers would decrease their costs – and some voluntarily did so – none lowered the worth of insulin. In July, Novo Nordisk raised its listing costs on two insulins one other 5 %.
Might by means of July would convey some of the toughest days, however Nicole and James pressed on, internet hosting a rally for reasonably priced insulin on the Minnesota state Capitol. Their story reached the ears of lawmakers: Within the state legislature, the Alec Smith Emergency Insulin Act was launched to present insulin to these in want. It didn’t come up for a vote, however they laminated a replica of the invoice’s textual content anyway.
On her first Mom’s Day with out Alec, Nicole spent hours planting a memorial backyard in a nook of her yard. Every week later, on Might 20, the household invited family members over to go to the area and commemorate Alec’s first “heavenly birthday.” Brittany had pushed a half-hour throughout the Wisconsin state line to purchase fireworks. Within the kitchen, there have been hamburgers and scorching canine ready. There was even a cake: store-bought with thick white frosting – the type a diabetic may be advised to keep away from. In inexperienced letters, it learn: “Forever 26.”
The lengthy Minnesota winter had given method to one of these good days, 70 levels and sunny. James fired up the grill, and music piped by way of audio system. The Borromes arrived, and so did Laine, who dabbed her eyes with a serviette as they shared tales about Alec.
For Nicole, it was an excessive amount of at occasions. When she wanted to, she retreated from the 40 individuals gathered and smoked a Newport alone on the deck. When James escorted a gaggle of Alec’s buddies over to the backyard, the place they sprinkled some of Alec’s ashes, Nicole backed away from the huddle, saying, “I can’t do this.” Some days, she advised me later, “it’s all a lot.”
Alec would proceed to be the face of a rising motion. In a number of weeks, a letter from Nicole can be learn at a convention in Washington about making prescription drugs reasonably priced. In June, throughout a listening to on rising drug costs with Azar, Democratic Sen. Tina Smith of Minnesota would invoke Nicole: “Her son Alec passed away last year because he couldn’t afford his insulin,” she informed Azar. Later in the summertime, Democratic senators would invite the household to Washington to share their story.
There can be a lot of time for extra activism, however at this time was meant for many who knew Alec greatest. At nightfall, Brittany handed out sparklers and Roman candles, and the gang gathered in a circle on the grass. They launched the fireworks into massive bursts of yellow and inexperienced, with sparks and ash raining down over the yard. It had been a tough day, however it was nonetheless a celebration. Nicole stood on the deck to report the scene on a cellphone as family and friends referred to as out: “Happy birthday, Alec!” “We love you!” “We miss you.” Everybody stared up on the sky, watching till the final flare burned out.